Demonstrations have broken out across the northern part of the country after the Supreme Court redefined the Aravalli hills – one of the world's oldest geological formations stretching across the states of Rajasthan, Haryana, Gujarat, and Delhi.
As per the revised criteria, endorsed by the court following central government recommendations, an Aravalli hill is any geographical feature rising at least 100 metres (328 ft) from the surrounding terrain. A cluster of such hills within 500 metres of each other, along with the land between them, are considered an Aravalli range.
Ecologists assert that defining Aravalli hills based on elevation could leave numerous lower, scrub-covered but vitally important hills unprotected from quarrying and development.
The federal government, however, says that the revised definition is designed to tighten controls and establish consistency and not weaken protections.
The Roots of the Unrest
Recently, calm demonstrations took place in cities such as Gurugram and Udaipur, led by local residents, farmers, environmental activists, and, at times, lawyers and political groups.
A founder member of a prominent environmental group stated that the new definition risks undermining the critical role of the Aravalli range in "preventing desertification, recharging groundwater and safeguarding local economies" in the northwestern region.
The lower, scrub-covered hills play a vital role in preventing desertification, recharging groundwater and sustaining communities as per experts.
"This mountain system should not be defined by height alone, but by its ecological, geological and climatic purpose," said an ecology advocate associated with the movement to save the Aravallis.
He pointed out that, globally, mountain ranges are identified by the functions they perform, not by arbitrary elevation thresholds.
"Any feature that is geologically part of the Aravalli system and serves a vital purpose in the ecosystem or preventing desertification should be recognised as part of the range, regardless of its height."
Activists are demanding that the government delineate Aravalli areas using scientific criteria, encompassing topography, biodiversity, wildlife connectivity and climate resilience.
A campaigner cautioned that the court's new definition could encourage extractive industries, development and business projects, heightening the threat of ecological damage.
Opposition parties have stepped up criticism, cautioning that the new definition could cause serious ecological damage.
A senior politician declared that safeguarding the Aravallis is "fundamentally linked to Delhi's survival." A different official described the range the state's "lifeline," adding that without it, "a vast region up to Delhi would have turned into a desert."
The Government's Stance
India's central government has sought to downplay these concerns.
In a recent communication, it said the new definition is intended to strengthen regulation and create standardization, adding that a single, objective definition was needed to regulate mining consistently across states.
It added that the new definition covers the whole mountainous region – incorporating slopes, related features, and intervening areas – explicitly protecting hill clusters and their linkages.
The federal environment ministry clarified it is incorrect to presume that mining will be allowed on all landforms under 100 metres.
The government states areas within the Aravalli hills or ranges are not eligible for new mining leases, while current operations can continue if they follow environmentally sound practices.
It noted that mining remains banned in core "protected" areas – protected forests, eco-sensitive zones, and wetlands – except for certain essential, national security, and nuclear minerals permitted by law.
The minister responsible for ecology indicated only about 2% of the 147,000 sqkm Aravalli range might be open to extraction, and only after comprehensive assessments and formal clearance.
However, several of the protesting groups say that demonstrations will continue and that they are exploring judicial avenues to challenge the court's new definition.