Skip to content
Discover winning strategies, expert tips, and the latest in…

The Platform X Wins Legal Challenge to Restore Viewing for Australian Users to Charlie Kirk Shooting Footage

Following a notable regulatory appeal, a national review panel has overturned a prior decision that prevented viewers in Australia from seeing video footage of the violent event involving influencer Charlie Kirk. The appeal was lodged by Elon Musk's social media platform, which contested an order sought by the online safety regulator.

Background on the Case and Ban

Following the fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk at a US campus in September, the eSafety commissioner applied to the review board to assess and rate the available footage. It first determined the content was "refused classification", a rating that allowed the commissioner to instruct social media companies to geo-block the posts for users in Australia.

The platform X challenged the decision for two separate videos depicting the Kirk incident. Additionally, it contested a similar ruling on another piece of footage—depicting the assault of Iryna Zarutska on a train in Charlotte—which had likewise been classified as "unacceptable for distribution".

Arguments Presented and Final Ruling

In its appeal, X contended that the Kirk video contained only brief violence with the weapon not shown. It was argued the recording was low-quality and the focus shifted rapidly from the individual to the bystanders.

X maintained the footage was not overly graphic, exploitative, or objectionable, stating it served as a factual documentation of "a significant incident of historical and political significance that generated extensive public discourse". The platform even compared the video and the historic film of the JFK shooting.

Most members of the classification panel concluded that, "despite the terrible nature of the event," the content did not reach a level that was exploitative, gratuitous, or offensive enough to justify a complete ban. However, they noted that a longer or clearer version with alternative commentary might have met that threshold. Consequently, the board changed the classification of the videos to R18+.

A Dissenting Opinion

A minority on the board disagreed, arguing the video was "content designed for sharing for the likely purposes of entertainment and/or personal gain (such as likes, shares, or views)". They also argued the comparison to the Zapruder JFK film was invalid, as the Kennedy video was released years after the event, "after public sentiment around the matter had calmed".

Reactions to the Decision

In a statement on its official policy channel, X expressed approval of the ruling.

"We challenged this case to uphold freedom of expression and the importance of access to information about issues of public interest. We remain dedicated to safeguarding these principles."

Representatives for the eSafety commissioner acknowledged the ruling, but noted that the revised classification now implies platforms "have obligations to prevent R18+ material being displayed to Australians who are minors".

Recent Developments on Sensitive Footage

In related news, the regulator did not issue take-down orders to social media companies this week regarding disturbing videos from the recent Bondi beach terror attack circulating on social media. The regulator stated that while the images were upsetting, they had not met the required standard for a "refused classification" rating.

As an alternative, the companies have been advised to apply sensitive content labels and interstitials, such as blurring, on such content in line with their own content policies.

The writer

Gina Rojas MD

A seasoned gaming analyst with over a decade of experience in casino operations and slot machine mechanics, specializing in player strategy development.

Slot Systems 715

Type to search articles.